Research & Education

Not All Probiotics Are Created Equal

Collaborative Roles of Foundational Bacteria Within a Coordinated System

In a healthy gut ecosystem, microbes rarely function in isolation. Instead, they participate in highly coordinated metabolic relationships that allow the community to remain stable, diverse, and adaptable. One of the most important of these relationships is cross-feeding. This cooperative behavior is a defining feature of resilient microbiomes and is consistently observed in health-associated microbial communities. In simple terms: one microbe’s output becomes another microbe’s fuel. When these cooperative relationships are intact, the microbiome tends to be more stable and adaptable. For example, Akkermansia muciniphila (Akkermansia) breaks down the mucus layer lining of the gut. The byproducts of that process, such as acetate, are then used by other bacteria, like Faecalibacterium prausnitzii (F. prausnitzii), to produce other short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs), such as butyrate. These compounds help nourish the gut lining and support normal immune signaling within the gastrointestinal (GI) tract. 

In contrast, when they are disrupted, the system may become more fragile. As diversity declines, so does the number of microbes capable of participating in these cooperative networks. When cross-feeding pathways are weakened, the microbiome may struggle to recover from common stressors, such as low-fiber diets, infections, or certain medications. This can show up as increased gut sensitivity, irregular digestion, or a general sense that the gut is “off”, even when no clear trigger is present. In these cases, adding individual bacterial strains without restoring the surrounding supportive network may only provide temporary support. 

Not All Probiotics Are Created Equal

Many probiotic formulas focus on variety. The outdated way of thinking is “the more bacteria, the better” to support a more diverse microbiome. Newer evidence is flipping this idea on its head, and it doesn’t reflect how healthy microbiomes are organized. In natural ecosystems, including the GI tract, stability is driven by foundational, core, keystone species. These organisms help structure the environment so others may survive. Without them, even a diverse population may struggle to sustain itself. Research increasingly suggests that certain bacteria play outsized roles in maintaining microbial balance through their interactions with the gut lining and other microbes. These organisms are often referred to as keystone or foundational species. Five bacteria stand out, each contributing a distinct but complementary function.

Akkermansia muciniphila: Supporting the Habitat 

Akkermansia plays a unique role by residing within, and gently breaking down, the gut’s mucus layer. This process stimulates ongoing mucin turnover, helping maintain a healthy mucus barrier that protects the intestinal lining while also serving as a nutrient-rich habitat for other beneficial microbes. As Akkermansia metabolizes mucin, it produces acetate and other metabolites that serve as substrates for downstream bacteria. In this way, Akkermansia shapes the gut's physical and metabolic environment, creating an ecological space that supports microbial diversity rather than displacing it.

Bifidobacterium longum (B. longum) and Bifidobacterium adolescentis (B. adolescentis): Feeding the Microbial Network

Bifidobacteria are key contributors to cross-feeding because of their ability to ferment complex carbohydrates and dietary fibers that many other microbes cannot utilize directly. Through this process, species such as B. longum and B. adolescentis produce acetate and lactate, SCFAs that fuel other keystone species, including F. prausnitzii. Bifidobacteria act as metabolic intermediates, helping to convert dietary inputs into forms that sustain butyrate-producing species

Faecalibacterium prausnitzii and Roseburia intestinalis (R. intestinalis): Primary Butyrate Producers 

F. prausnitzii and R. intestinalis are among the most prolific butyrate-producing bacteria in the human colon. Butyrate is a SCFA that serves as the primary energy source for intestinal cells and helps support normal barrier integrity and immune signaling at the gut lining. These organisms rely on upstream metabolites, including acetate, generated by Akkermansia and Bifidobacteria species to sustain their metabolic activity. When these cross-feeding relationships are intact, butyrate production is more consistent, supporting a calm, well-regulated intestinal environment. Importantly, F. prausnitzii and R. intestinalis are consistently depleted in states of reduced microbial diversity, as seen in populations adopting a primarily Western lifestyle. This association underscores their role as indicators of a healthy, well-adapted, and stable ecosystem rather than transient colonizers.

Together, these five foundational species form a collaborative relationship that helps support overall gut health and resilience. Each one fills a different role, from helping to support the gut’s lining to producing metabolic fuels, but it’s their coordination that makes them foundational. Together, they can crowd out potentially problematic bacteria by creating a strong, resilient ecosystem. It’s not about the number of bacteria present; it’s the right numbers of the right microbes working collaboratively that is important.

Learn more about the human microbiome: 

The Gut Ecosystem: Why Diversity Matters

What Are Keystone Probiotics Species?

Two Next-Generation Probiotics You Should Know About: Anaerostipes and Akkermansia

Fueling the Gut: How Anaerostipes Caccae Powers Butyrate Production

By Bri Mesenbring, MS, CNS, LDN